Indiana is home to six unique Goodwill Outlets (also known as “Goodwill Bins”), where thrifters and bargain hunters can discover incredible deals on clothing, home goods, toys, and more. You can easily find items sold by the pound for as low as $1.99 per pound. These outlets offer a thrilling, treasure-hunt experience, with new inventory rotated hourly and the chance to score high-quality items at unbeatable prices.
Pro Tips for First-Timers:
- Arrive Early: Fresh bins mean the best finds.
- Bring Gloves: Some items may need extra handling.
- Pack Patience: The lively atmosphere is part of the fun!
Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or a curious newbie, Indiana’s Goodwill Outlets deliver unique finds, unbeatable prices, and a chance to give back to your community.
Goodwill Outlets in Indiana
1) Goodwill Outlet Store – Indianapolis
The Goodwill Outlet Store in Indianapolis operates as a unique thrift shopping experience where most items are sold by weight rather than individual pricing.
Clothing, housewares, glassware, media, and toys are priced at $1.59 per pound, while books are sold separately at $0.50 for paperbacks and $0.75 for hardback. Furniture and showcase items receive individual pricing rather than per-pound rates.
Gloves are highly recommended since customers dig through large bins that may contain sharp objects or dusty items. The store features large tables and bathtub-sized bins filled with various items, and employees rotate these bins 9 to 10 times a day to add fresh merchandise.
2) Goodwill Outlet – Evansville
The Goodwill Outlet at 500 S Green River Road, Evansville, IN 47715, specializes in bulk thrift shopping where everything is sold by the pound, making it ideal for treasure hunters and bargain enthusiasts alike.
Most items including clothes, shoes, toys, electronics, glassware, and household goods are sold at $1.99 per pound, while books are priced at only 50¢ each. Larger furniture items are individually marked, and items over 15 pounds may receive special pricing at management discretion. Shoppers should come prepared with gloves and closed-toe shoes, as items are displayed in large bins and sold “as-is” with all sales being final.
The outlet has implemented safety guidelines including waiting for bins to stop moving before browsing and maintaining a family-friendly atmosphere where children must stay with adults at all times.
3) Goodwill Outlet Store – Clarksville
Goodwill Outlet Store in Clarksville, Indiana (1212 Applegate Ln) is part of the Goodwill of Central and Southern Indiana empire. This outlet’s hallmark is the “bins” system where people can shop by the pound across categories like clothing, housewares, books, media, toys, and small furniture.
Most items including clothing, housewares, glassware, media and toys are sold by the pound at $1.59 per pound, while books are priced at $0.50 for paperbacks and $0.75 for hardbacks. Larger items like furniture are individually priced as marked.
The bins rotate every hour throughout the day, with new merchandise being brought out to replace existing bins, creating fresh shopping opportunities. Regular customers recommend wearing gloves (and even ear protection), bringing a friend for support, and arriving early especially if you’re hunting for high-value items.
4) Goodwill Outlet Store – Franklin Rd
The Goodwill Outlet at 4105 N Franklin Rd operates as a “pay‑by‑the‑pound” thrift store where most items are purchased based on weight, typically between $1.29 and $1.89 per pound. This outlet is part of Goodwill Central & Southern Indiana’s network, which funnels unsold goods from its retail locations into these bulk‑sale stores.
Gloves are highly recommended for shoppers since you’ll be digging through bins that may contain dusty or rough items like glass. The bins are rotated typically every hour throughout the day.
Recent customer reviews indicate that the quality and quantity of items has declined, with better merchandise being pulled for Goodwill’s online auction site, and rotations taking longer than in previous years.
5) Goodwill Outlet Store – Greenwood
The Goodwill Outlet Store in Greenwood operates as a warehouse-style thrift store where items are sold by the pound rather than individually priced.
Located at 927 N Emerson Ave, the store charges $1.59 per pound for most items including clothing, housewares, glassware, media, and toys. Books are priced separately at $0.50 for paperbacks and $0.75 for hardbacks, while furniture and showcase items receive individual pricing.
The bins rotate every 45-60 minutes with fresh merchandise replacing the previous selections. While gloves are not mandatory, they are highly recommended for digging through bins that may contain broken glass, dusty items, or other rough materials.
While there’s only one cashier station, most shoppers report quick service, and the store is well‑liked for maintaining a tidy environment and a steady supply of new items as bins are rotated during the day.
6) Goodwill Outlet Store – Gary
The Goodwill Outlet Store in Gary (also known as the “bins”) is located at 4830 W Ridge Rd, Gary, IN 46408, and is part of the Goodwill Industries of Michiana region. Unlike traditional thrift stores, this outlet sells items by the pound, typically ranging from $0.50 to $1.99 per pound, making it a favorite among bargain hunters and resellers alike.
The Gary goodwill outlet is described as one of the newest ones, being cleaner and way calmer, which makes for a smoother shopping experience. It features well-organized bins segregated by category including clothing, books, media, small appliances, and more, which are refreshed frequently.
Regulars recommend arriving early when the store opens for the best selections, packing gloves for sifting through bins, and expecting that some Mondays and Sundays might see fewer items due to restocking.